madathome7.JPG

mapleleaf5b.JPG Welcome to the Mad River Institute for Political Studies

Our View:

‘Gorgeous Guergis’ Not So Pretty Any More

Under normal circumstances, we would probably wait until after the RCMP investigation has concluded but, since Helena Guergis is our local MP here in Simcoe-Grey, we thought it only reasonable to share some thoughts on her being dropped from Cabinet,  put out of the Conservative caucus and, now, dropped as their candidate in the riding.

When she was victorious in the 2004 federal election, defeating Liberal incumbent Paul Bonwick by 100 votes, the surprise was by how little she won. Simcoe-Grey only elects Conservatives ... under normal circumstances. However, during the latter 1990s, with the right-wing split between PCs and Reformers (then Canadian Alliance), Bonwick was able to slip up the middle. Nevertheless, much was made of Guergis’ win. Many saw her as fresh and new.

She gained little ink from the media until nearly the end of her first term. At the time, Paul Martin was desperately trying to save his Liberal minority. Though Belinda Stronach had been important in the union that created the new Conservative Party, disdain from leader Stephen Harper and, perhaps, a reconsideration of her policy positions, caused her to ‘cross the floor’ of Parliament and join the Liberals. Guergis, with colleague Joe Preston, pushed a private member’s bill that would have forced anyone switching sides to resign and seek re-election under the banner of their new party. Right after the 2006 election, Guergis’ office sent out a press release renewing her commitment to the bill, with a statement a further release would give a date when she would re-present it. However, almost immediately, she was promoted to Parliamentary Secretary to David Emerson, a newly re-elected Liberal who had just crossed the floor to sit as a Conservative Cabinet minister. Neither the second press release, nor the bill, ever saw the light of day. It was the first sign that political advancement took precedence over principle.

The second sign of trouble came after her promotion as a junior Cabinet minister, Secretary of State for Foreign Affairs and International Trade. When it turned out she was in Mexico, just 20 minutes from the jail cell where Canadian Brenda Martin had been held for two years, and then did not visit the prisoner, many saw this as not doing the job. She agreed. "That's not my job. There are 13 Canadians in Mexican jails and if I visit one, I have to visit them all", Guergis was quoted as saying. "It's not my job to meet them. It's my job to advocate for them." It seemed pretty cold-hearted and undiplomatic.

And then came this past February’s Charlottetown airport meltdown, tagged as the "hissy fit". Arriving just minutes before her flight to Ottawa was to leave, Guergis initially balked at the pre-boarding screening, then apparently refused to remove her shoes, setting off the metal detector’s alarm. When asked to try again, she allegedly slammed her boots into the bin and swore, "Happy fucking birthday to me. I guess I'm stuck in this hell-hole". She then is said to have beat on the glass of the boarding area and yelled loudly. The minister never confirmed nor denied the report, simply apologizing to islanders.

At that time, and since, there were those in the media who called for Guergis to be dropped from Cabinet. We take the view she was never qualified to have been in Cabinet in the first place and would not have been except Stephen Harper wanted a pretty face over his right shoulder on House of Commons’ TV. In defending her, which he had done on many occasions, the Prime Minister was saying a lot about the quality of his caucus. If he really had no one better than her for Cabinet, then that speaks volumes about the other 110 Conservative MPs not in Cabinet.

Byron Montgomery, President

* * * * *

The "Idle Canadian" Awards

Worst Politicians of 2009

Each year we choose those in public service who our members believe have disappointed Canadians the most.

In another sadly forgettable year, we looked at numerous worthy candidates.

The Worst Federal Member of Parliament was ... a tie ... between last year’s winner ... Stephen Harper, Prime Minister of Canada, and his Opposition opposite, Liberal leader Michael Ignatieff

- Harper, for undemocratic actions which have led to perhaps the least accountable Canadian government ever, at the expense of average Canadians;

- for continuing to bully his opponents with more negative advertising, this time aimed at the new Liberal leader;

- for having the Governor-General prorogue, again, this time to hide the facts behind an apparent cover-up regarding the abuse of Afghan detainees;

- for a stimulus budget that practically throws money at ineffective, short-term programmes at the expense of long-term infrastructure.

- Ignatieff, for failing to make his party the real Official Opposition. Early in the year, he had his Liberals simply back Conservative actions while criticizing but not offering alternatives. Later in the year, he stated the Liberals would oppose all Conservative actions in order to force an election, without offering alternatives.

- for wasting a year when he could have had his party adopt policies for which to stand;

- for his speeches where he essentially says it’s his destiny to be Prime Minister.

The Worst Provincial M.P.P./M.L.A./M.N.A. was ... another tie ... between Dalton McGuinty, Premier of Ontario and Gordon Campbell, Premier of British Columbia

- McGuinty, for introducing the Harmonized Sales Tax (HST) with no public consultation. In fact, he doesn’t appear to have told the members of his own caucus, or finance minister, before making the decision;

- for scandals at Crown agencies eHealth and Ontario Lottery & Gaming that, with proper oversight, would likely never have happened

- Campbell, for introducing the HST with no public consultation; in fact, he announced it just two months after a provincial election during which he said his party had "no plans" to implement an HST;

- for the Olympic hangover that will be left after the games end – a huge deficit, probably in the hundreds of millions of dollars, that was promised would never happen.

- for the arrogance of saying he wants to beat the record of W.A.C. Bennett of 20 years as premier.

NB: Interestingly, Manitoba has rejected an HST ... after public consultations.

The Worst Municipal Councillor was ...Tony Guergis, Warden of Simcoe County and Mayor of Springwater Township, Ontario

- for flip-flopping on the issue, then ignoring overwhelming public sentiment and attempting to force the construction of a landfill, Site 41, on the top of a watershed that supplies fresh drinking water for as many as 4 million people;

- for promoting the idea Simcoe County should become Ontario’s newest regional government, apparently so he and his fellow councillors could get extra powers and pay.

The Worst International Politician was ...Hamid Karzai, President of Afghanistan

- for corruption; his own in cheating in the election that saw him re-elected as president (an election he would likely have won anyway, just not as easily);

- for tolerating the Taliban, violence, fraud, the drug trade, and most every other social vice to stay in power.

The Worst Civil Servant was ...Sarah Kramer, then Chief Executive Officer, eHealth Ontario

- for $16 million in untendered contracts; excessively high travel and catering expenses and consultants' fees that bordered on the obscene. This agency, tasked to create a system for electronic health records, was well behind. As a result, it seems accountability was dismissed in favour of speed. Yet other jurisdictions have established e-records. Couldn’t eHealth have just bought into the technology?

Lifetime Lack of Achievement Award

All the "do-nothing" politicians in Canada (You know who you are ...)

- for getting elected, then sitting back and just doing what you’re told, collecting ever-larger paycheques, then getting re-elected again and again, while just sucking at the public trough. Oh, it might be said if the voters choose you over and over, it’s just democracy ... but given you have so many advantages as an incumbent, it’s not fair. Here’s hoping to get your comeuppance in your next election!

Rules:

  • Must be nominated by an Institute member.
  • Must be an active politician for all categories but the ‘lifetime’ award.
  • Must be an active civil servant or one still "in the news".
  • For lifetime award, must have been out of politics long enough to evaluate policies and political decisions or, if still active, have a long track record.
  • "Winners" selected by Board of Directors.

The Mad River Institute for Political Studies is dedicated to raising standards of ethics, accountability, and responsibility throughout society.

********************************************************************************************************** 

Read our NEW January 2010  Clarion Call !!!

It includes thoughts on public union strikes, wind turbines, H1N1, pension and Senate reform.

**********************************************************************************************************

Click on the link to see who 'won' our past "Idle Canadian" Awards. 

**********************************************************************************************************

If you'd like your say on this or any political issue, log onto our new blog at Opinions.

Take a look at our brand new OnLine Store! Fifty percent of all proceeds go to the Institute.

Check out our work on municipal government in the Local Reform Initiative.

If you would like to subscribe to our newsletter, just hit this link and type 'Subscribe' in the Subject line.

*******************************************************************************************************************************

This site was last updated on Thursday, 6 May 2010.

*****

Mad River Institute for Political Studies, Creemore & London, Ontario